Tag Archives: Census at Bethlehem

Pieter Bruegel the Elder’s Census at Bethlehem (1566)

Last Sun­day, my fam­i­ly and I attend­ed a Christ­mas car­ol ser­vice at our local church, resplen­dent, as every year, with can­dle­light and sea­son­al good­will. As well as the age-old car­ols that we all know and love (or at least tol­er­ate fond­ly, after the decades of rep­e­ti­tion), there were of course sev­er­al appo­site read­ings, and it is the one below, from Luke 2:1–5, that inspired the sub­ject of today’s blog.

And it came to pass in those days that a decree went out from Cae­sar Augus­tus that all the world should be reg­is­tered… So all went to be reg­is­tered, every­one to his own city. Joseph also went up from Galilee, out of the city of Nazareth, into Judea, to the city of David, which is called Beth­le­hem, because he was of the house and lin­eage of David, to be reg­is­tered with Mary, his betrothed wife, who was with child.

This of course refers to the cen­sus at Beth­le­hem, and the scene was depict­ed won­der­ful­ly well (albeit set anachro­nis­ti­cal­ly and anatopis­ti­cal­ly in 16th cen­tu­ry Flan­ders) in this 1566 oil paint­ing by one of my favourite artists, Pieter Bruegel the Elder. As is usu­al with works by this Nether­lan­dish Renais­sance mas­ter, much plea­sure is derived from view­ing the piece up close and dis­cov­er­ing the mul­ti­tude of details.

We are look­ing down on a snow-cov­ered vil­lage (and indeed this is one of the first exam­ples of snowy land­scape in West­ern art, the pre­vi­ous win­ter of 1565 hav­ing been, not unco­in­ci­den­tal­ly, one of the harsh­est on record). Peo­ple are going about their dai­ly busi­ness: clear­ing the snow, cross­ing the frozen pond, warm­ing them­selves around a fire. The chil­dren are throw­ing snow­balls, skat­ing, sledg­ing, spin­ning tops. In the right hand fore­ground, we see a man with a large car­pen­ter’s saw, lead­ing an ox and an ass, on which rides a woman wrapped up tight­ly against the cold. These are of course none oth­er than Joseph and Mary, who have come to Beth­le­hem to be enrolled in the uni­ver­sal cen­sus ordered by Emper­or Augus­tus.

With a few deft brush­strokes Bruegel bril­liant­ly cap­tures vil­lage life, whilst sub­tly depict­ing the scene just pri­or to the nativ­i­ty (since after reg­is­ter­ing, there was, of course, no room at the inn). I could spend ages glimps­ing new details revealed in Bruegel’s works, and indeed have done on sev­er­al occa­sions in var­i­ous gal­leries of Europe, where I have usu­al­ly been left to it, meet­ing my long-suf­fer­ing fam­i­ly lat­er in the gift shop! Fun­ni­ly enough, this piece I have yet to actu­al­ly see (it’s in Brus­sels’ Musée des Beaux Arts, which is still only “on the list”).