Tag Archives: Thicker Than Water

Laurel & Hardy in Thicker Than Water (1935)

Stan Lau­rel and Oliv­er Hardy were arguably the most suc­cess­ful com­e­dy team of all time, thriv­ing dur­ing the ear­ly Clas­si­cal Hol­ly­wood era of Amer­i­can cin­e­ma from the late 1920s to the mid-1940s. Known and loved through­out the world under a large vari­ety of names (among them Dick und Doof
in Ger­many, Flip i Flap in Poland, and Cric e Croc in Italy), to the Eng­lish-speak­ing world they were of course Lau­rel and Hardy: Stan the love­able sim­ple­ton and Olly the ambi­tious but pompous butt of many a “fine mess”.

The duo, like W C Fields and the Marx Broth­ers, had deep roots in stage and music
hall before mak­ing the suc­cess­ful tran­si­tion from stage to screen. Stan Lau­rel began his career, when he was plain Arthur Jef­fer­son, as Char­lie Chaplin’s under­study when they were both sta­ble­mates of “Fred Karno’s army”, Karno being an influ­en­tial the­atre impre­sario and pio­neer of slap­stick com­e­dy. Oliv­er Hardy, mean­while, was cut­ting his teeth per­form­ing vaude­ville and work­ing for the Lubin motion pic­ture pro­duc­tion com­pa­ny, appear­ing in scores of one-reel­er movies, most­ly play­ing the “heavy”. Their paths began to cross when both worked for Hal Roach Stu­dios in the ear­ly 1920s, but it was in 1927 that the two shared screen time togeth­er in the silent com­e­dy films, Slip­ping Wives, Duck Soup, and With Love and Hiss­es. The pos­i­tive audi­ence reac­tions to the pair­ing was not­ed, and a com­e­dy duo was born, and then cement­ed as they trans­ferred so per­fect­ly to the advent of the talkies.

Their com­e­dy tim­ing was impec­ca­ble, their phys­i­cal com­e­dy honed to per­fec­tion. With a pair of unmis­take­able, born-for-com­e­dy faces and phys­i­cal mor­phol­o­gy, just look­ing at a pic­ture of them is enough to bring a smile to the face. Whilst so much ear­ly com­e­dy has become dat­ed, the com­e­dy of Lau­rel and Hardy remains time­less, a whole eighty-odd years lat­er. Tes­ta­ment to their endur­ing charm is the large group of mod­ern-day Lau­rel and Hardy fans known as the “Sons of the Desert” (tak­en from their 1933 film of the same name) with chap­ters all over the world. A few years ago I took the fam­i­ly to a screen show­ing of some Lau­rel & Hardy reels at Birstall, and was both amused and reas­sured to see some of the chaps in the audi­ence sport­ing the trade­mark Sons of the Desert fez! I was equal­ly delight­ed to see my young daugh­ters lap­ping up the phys­i­cal com­e­dy and gig­gling at these gags from a dis­tant age.

Here, I have cho­sen a nice clip of the two get­ting into typ­i­cal­ly amus­ing both­er, with Olly, as usu­al, pay­ing for his impe­ri­ous and blus­ter­ing treat­ment of Stan, by com­ing off con­sid­er­ably the worst. It’s from the 1935 film, Thick­er Than Water.

 

Lau­rel & Hardy